Want more Italian dishes? Try Chicken Cacciatore, Homemade Lasagna, or Tomato and Basil Bruschetta.
Why we Stef and Alex love this recipe:
Creamy: There is no sauce creamier than a Cacio e Pepe sauce! Try it and see! Flavorful: Pepper is at the top of the list of this flavor-filled recipe. Affordable: It has just a few simple ingredients, just pasta, pepper, and pecorino cheese!
How to make Cacio e Pepe:
The creaminess of this recipe is not due to the addition of cream but is made with pasta water, which contains a large amount of starch and gives the final dish the right softness. So don’t drain it in the sink but keep it until the end of the preparation of this dish. Boil Pasta: Remember that making this pasta is all about timing. It’s best to note the time when you add the pasta water to make the creamy cheese. Set the timer and use the water two minutes after the pasta is cooked because that’s the time that has the most starch to make a smooth, creamy cheese mixture. Toast Pepper: Use a steel pan and toast the freshly ground pepper. The heat should be very low. When you smell the aroma, add some hot pasta water. Make Sauce: Grate the pecorino cheese in a bowl; use a microplane so that the cheese is fine like powder. Two minutes after cooking the pasta, add a small ladleful of pasta water and whisk it until it forms a lump-free cream. Should it be too stiff, add a little water at a time, but just enough because you don’t want a sauce that is too runny. Serve: With the heat off, combine the ingredients. Add the pasta to the pepper water, then the cheese mixture. Mix it well and vigorously; add a little more water if it has any lumps. Serve the best Cacio e Pepe recipe hot, adding some more grated pepper for decoration.
Pro Tips:
No Oil: The cheese provides enough fat; therefore, no extra oil is needed. Pasta Water: Use only the hot pasta water, which contains the starch and that which makes the cream silky and smooth without any lumps. Do not use too much water to cook the pasta because the starch itself makes the sauce smooth and creamy. Don’t Cook Pasta Completely: Drain the pasta before it is finished cooking. Finish cooking it in the skillet with the ground toasted peppercorns so that the spaghetti will absorb the full taste.
Can you store the cacio e pepe for the next day?
No, you can’t. Cacio e pepe must be prepared and eaten right away. It cannot be stored in the refrigerator, so prepare the right serving for each person.
Serve With:
Artisan No Knead Bread Pomegranate and Pear Salad Mixed Green Salad with Berries
Visit Stefania’s Kitchenette for more authentic Italian Recipes! This post contains affiliate links.
